Breaking: former fourth overall pick and Philly native replace Dallas Goedert
The Philadelphia Eagles’ renewed commitment to Dallas Goedert and his postseason experience make him the better choice for a team aiming for another championship, even though Kyle Pitts has intriguing promise.
Although Kyle Pitts has intriguing upside potential, it would be a risky move that would conflict with the Eagles’ championship window to trade for him in place of Dallas Goedert. Goedert is the safer pick for 2025 because of his demonstrated postseason performance and recently renegotiated contract. Some pundits question whether the Eagles should target the former fourth overall pick as a replacement for Dallas Goedert, given reports that other teams have contacted the Atlanta Falcons regarding Kyle Pitts’ availability. Following months of hesitancy, Goedert and the Eagles reached an agreement on a renegotiated contract that would pay him $10 million through 2025 plus an additional $1 million in incentives.
One of the NFL’s most intriguing “what if” players is still Pitts. He is 24 years old, earning $10.9 million on his fifth-year option, and he offers substantial upside at a price that is almost the same as Goedert’s. The former Florida standout became the second tight end in NFL history to reach 1,000 yards in his debut season with 68 receptions for 1,026 yards. At six feet six and 250 pounds, his physical prowess is undeniable.
However, Pitts has had health and production issues ever since that outstanding rookie campaign. Last season, he managed just 602 yards and four touchdowns on 47 receptions, giving him a total of just 1,625 receiving yards over the previous three seasons. Those figures are insignificant compared to what the Eagles require from their main tight end.
Even though Goedert has struggled with injuries, missing 15 games in the last three seasons, he has continuously produced well when healthy. Most importantly, he has performed well under pressure. Goedert has 52 receptions for 562 yards and four touchdowns in 12 career playoff games. During the Eagles’ recent run to the Super Bowl, he led the team with 17 receptions for 215 yards and a touchdown, which is the second-most by an Eagle in a single postseason.
Goedert’s retention is also supported by financial factors. According to reports, Atlanta would need to select Pitts with at least a second or third-round pick. It would seem illogical for a reigning champion with little draft resources to spend premium picks on a position where they already had a proven commodity. With the growth of Grant Calcaterra and the addition of Harrison Bryant and Kylen Granson, the Eagles have increased the depth of their tight end position.
Pitts certainly has exceptional athletic skills, but the Eagles’ present priorities don’t coincide with the time. At a fair price, Goedert is a proven player who has performed well during championship moments. Riding with the veteran who has already shown he can produce on the greatest stage is a safer option for a team looking to protect their title. The best trades aren’t always the ones you make.
