Collingwood Magpies legend Tony Shaw has compiled a list of players he has had the privilege to watch throughout his time with the team. This list reflects not only the players’ individual skills and achievements but also their impact on the club’s history. Here’s a detailed look at Shaw’s top 5 selections and what made each player stand out.

5. Peter McKenna
Peter McKenna, renowned for his remarkable goal-scoring ability, was a prolific forward for Collingwood from 1968 to 1980. His knack for kicking goals and his presence in the forward line made him one of the most dangerous forwards of his era. McKenna’s legacy is defined by his impressive goal tally and his role in several memorable games for the Magpies.

4. Scott Pendlebury
Scott Pendlebury, a modern icon for Collingwood, has been a linchpin for the team since his debut in 2006. His exceptional skills as a midfielder, along with his leadership qualities, have made him a central figure in the team’s recent successes. Pendlebury’s ability to read the game and his influence on the field have solidified his place among the Magpies’ all-time greats.

3. Nathan Buckley
Nathan Buckley, who played for Collingwood from 1993 to 2010, is widely regarded as one of the greatest players in the club’s history. His extraordinary skill set, combined with his leadership and determination, made him a standout midfielder. Buckley’s career was marked by his consistency and his role in driving the team towards premiership success.

2. Phil Carman
Phil Carman, known for his explosive play and scoring prowess, was a dynamic forward for Collingwood in the 1970s. His ability to make an impact in crucial moments and his exceptional skill set earned him a high place on Shaw’s list. Carman’s influence on the game and his exciting style of play left a lasting impression on the Magpies’ fans.

1. Peter Daicos
At the top of Shaw’s list is Peter Daicos, often hailed as one of the most talented players ever to wear the Collingwood jersey. Daicos, known for his incredible goal-scoring ability and flair on the field, is a true Magpies legend. His creative play and exceptional skill made him a standout player and a beloved figure in Collingwood’s storied history.

Tony Shaw’s list captures the essence of Collingwood’s rich history and the players who have left an indelible mark on the club. Each of these legends brought something unique to the team, shaping the Magpies’ legacy with their remarkable contributions.